An independent mediator’s perspective on artificial intelligence, doing your homework, and why being informed isn’t necessarily the same as being right.
Let’s imagine someone walking into mediation armed with 47 pages of ChatGPT research, three proposed settlement agreements, a breakdown of their legal rights, and absolute confidence that they’re going to win.
Fantastic. At least they’ve done their homework.
There’s just one small problem.
ChatGPT has probably only heard their side of the story.
Artificial intelligence is changing how people access information. Questions that once required hours of research can now receive detailed responses in seconds. Legal terminology can be explained in plain English, complicated documents can be summarised, and possible solutions can be explored without immediately involving a professional.
So, as a mediator, do I think people should use AI when dealing with divorce, separation, workplace disagreements, business disputes or litigation?
Generally speaking, yes.
In fact, I’d encourage people to become better informed about the issues they’re facing.
But there’s an important distinction between using AI to understand a problem and using AI to convince yourself that you’re right.
Before Mediation: Do Your Homework
Mediation works better when people understand what they’re discussing.
If you’re going through a divorce, for example, there’s nothing wrong with using AI to understand concepts such as maintenance, parental responsibilities, division of assets or settlement agreements.
If you’re involved in a business dispute, AI might help you understand contractual terminology, identify relevant questions or organise the information you need to discuss.
It can also help you prepare a list of concerns, explore different settlement scenarios and identify matters you may not have considered.
That’s useful preparation.
However, AI-generated information isn’t automatically correct. Legal principles vary between jurisdictions, and even within South Africa, the application of a legal principle can depend heavily on the facts and circumstances.
AI can misunderstand those facts, overlook exceptions or confidently provide information that is outdated or simply wrong.
Use it to identify questions worth investigating. Verify important legal information through reliable sources or a suitably qualified attorney.
Understanding what the law generally says is not the same as understanding how it applies to your particular situation.
The Problem With Asking AI Who Is Right
Here’s where things become interesting.
Suppose you ask ChatGPT:
“My ex is refusing to give me what I’m legally entitled to. How can I make them comply?”
Look carefully at that question.
You’ve already established that you’re entitled to something. You’ve already decided the other person is refusing to cooperate. And you’ve framed the entire issue around making them comply.
Perhaps you’re correct.
But perhaps there’s information you haven’t considered. Perhaps the other person understands the agreement differently. Perhaps the legal position isn’t quite as straightforward as you believe.
AI may challenge your assumptions. It may also respond within the framework you’ve provided.
Now consider asking a different question:
“What legal and practical considerations might apply to this dispute? What information could change my understanding, and what reasonable arguments might the other party raise?”
Same technology. Different approach.
The first question seeks support for a position.
The second seeks understanding.
And that distinction matters enormously in mediation.
AI can help you challenge your thinking, or it can become a very sophisticated way of agreeing with yourself.
Should You Use AI During Mediation?
I don’t see anything inherently wrong with someone wanting to research an issue or better understand a proposal before making a decision.
In fact, people should understand what they’re agreeing to.
But consider a common question:
“ChatGPT, is this settlement fair?”
Fair according to whom?
Fair under the law? Fair financially? Fair when considering the time and cost of litigation? Fair in terms of the parties’ individual needs?
A settlement doesn’t exist in isolation. There are legal, financial, practical and personal considerations.
One person might place enormous value on keeping a particular asset. Another might prefer financial certainty, even if that means accepting less than they initially requested.
AI can help examine the options.
But it cannot determine what matters most to you, and it shouldn’t make that decision on your behalf.
There is also the issue of confidentiality.
Mediation often involves sensitive personal, financial and business information. Uploading documents or copying private discussions into an AI platform may create confidentiality and data-protection concerns.
Before sharing anything, consider the applicable confidentiality arrangements, whether the information belongs to someone else, and how the AI service handles submitted data.
If you’re uncertain, ask your mediator or attorney before uploading it.
What About Using AI During Litigation?
AI can be useful when preparing questions for an attorney, understanding unfamiliar legal terminology or organising information.
However, litigation carries additional risks.
Court procedures, filing requirements, deadlines and legal authorities must be accurate. AI systems can produce incorrect legal references, misunderstand procedural requirements or invent cases that do not exist.
A convincing answer is not necessarily a correct answer.
If you’re involved in litigation, use AI as a supplementary research and preparation tool, not as your sole source of legal advice.
A qualified attorney remains important when you need advice on your legal position, procedural obligations or the consequences of a decision.
Five Useful Questions to Ask AI Before Mediation
If you’re going to use AI to prepare for mediation, consider asking questions that help you explore the dispute rather than simply reinforce your position.
- “What information and documents should I prepare before discussing this dispute?”
- “What assumptions might I be making about the other party’s position?”
- “What are the possible advantages, disadvantages and practical consequences of the settlement options I’m considering?”
- “What questions should I ask my mediator or attorney before making a decision?”
- “What alternative solutions might address both parties’ underlying concerns?”
These questions won’t resolve the dispute for you.
But they may help you arrive better prepared to have a productive conversation.
Avoid entering identifying details or confidential information when using these prompts.
Information Alone Doesn’t Resolve Conflict
One of the most important things I’ve learned about conflict is that people don’t always disagree because they lack information.
Sometimes they understand the facts perfectly well.
They simply disagree about what those facts mean, what should happen next, or what they’re prepared to accept.
A person may know that a settlement proposal is financially reasonable and still reject it because they feel disrespected, unheard or treated unfairly.
That doesn’t necessarily make them unreasonable. It makes them human.
Mediation creates an opportunity to explore those underlying concerns and help people move towards agreements they can understand, accept and implement.
AI may assist with that process, but information is only part of the equation.
My Position
Bring your research. Bring your questions. Bring your spreadsheets if you must.
I have no objection to people taking the time to understand their circumstances and explore their options.
In fact, I encourage it.
But don’t bring a ChatGPT response expecting it to settle the argument.
An AI-generated answer isn’t a court ruling, a legal opinion or an agreement between the parties.
Use AI to become better informed, to question your assumptions and to prepare for meaningful discussions.
And remember that the objective of mediation isn’t to prove that your research is better than the other person’s.
It’s to find a way forward that the people involved can actually agree to.
Because if information alone could resolve every dispute, most of us wouldn’t need mediators in the first place.
Help! I’m Stuck in the Middle of a Dispute — How Mediation Can Help
Being involved in a dispute can feel overwhelming. You may be asking yourself: The good news…
Mediation Q&A
Is mediation like therapy? Absolutely not, mediators cannot make judgements, diagnosis or attempt to be psychologists.…
Reading Between the Lines: Understanding Body Language
Humans communicate constantly, but not always with words. A twitching foot, a raised eyebrow, or crossed…






